The 1985 movie version of a A
Room with a View, written by E. M. Forster, is basically about
a young woman coming from a high social class who meets a young man in
Florence, Italy but finds herself trapped between high social class demands and
what her heart wants. Since the beginning of the movie I recognized the
difference in social classes. For example, when Lucy Honeychurch and her cousin
Charlotte are dining with a novel writer who was talking all sorts of complex
and proper words, while a man named Emerson and his son George were trying to
be nice and offered their room with a view to Lucy and Charlotte.
Throughout the movie I noticed how Lucy
was passionate about many things but felt limited because of what was
considered proper for a lady. As soon as George kisses Lucy, Charlotte and her
cousin leave Florence. Charlotte considered the act improper and Lucy due to
her background had to think it was improper too. Later on, Lucy is
engaged to an intectual man named Cecil. Her fiancé was not compatible with
Lucy at all, but she thought it was correct to marry a man with
class. Cecil was constantly reading books, while Lucy liked to bath
in the sacred lake (but no longer because she was caught) and play tennis with
her brother. Later on, Mr. Emerson moves in next the Honeychurches and George
(visited him in the weekends) became good friends with Lucy's brother, Freddy
Honeychurch. During this time George kisses Lucy once again and he tries to
convince Lucy that Cecil does not love her. He tried to convince her that she
felt different after Florence. Lucy, thinking about what George said, breaks
off her engagement with Cecil and decides to go to Greece. For me, this trip to
Greece was just a way of escaping everything.
In the entire movie, I saw how the high
class had so many rules and limits and Lucy had trouble with this. As a young
woman she liked to experience adventure and wanted romance in her life. In one
scene were they were riding through Italy, the driver seemed to be romantic
with a girl and while the others considered it disrespectful, Lucy thought
their affection was harmless. Today we have cases similar to this. There may be
young people who's parents want them to acquire a specific profesion or they
expect them to marry specific type of people. Thankfully, in most modern day
societies, but not in all cultures, young people have a voice and have the
liberty of chosing their future. It still surprises me though, how some people
take this for granted while some teenagers in other countries cant't even
decide what to wear, where to go or even who they marry.
Arrange marriages seem almost unreal, but they were, and still are, a plague that is all too real. Men and women should be free to chose their life partner. Great review!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteI sometimes wonder how people could live that way, how they couldn't make any real decisions in their life. That's no way to live.
ReplyDeleteOne of the most interesting points in the film was watching Lucy be herself and not trying to adapt into what society have established is supposed to be a lady, and how that helped her find her identity and love.
ReplyDelete